Biyografi Dünyası
Osmanlı Subayı

The Ottoman Lieutenant

Movie · 2017 · 6 people

Written by Jeff Stockwell and directed by Joseph Ruben, the American-Turkish The Ottoman Lieutenant (Osmanlı Subayı) is set in wartime, around 1915, as a romantic drama released in 2017. It was filmed in English and runs about 106 minutes. It was released in the United States on 10 March 2017 and in Türkiye on 19 May 2017.

At its centre is Lillie, an idealistic American nurse bringing help to a hospital in eastern Anatolia. After a punishing sixty-day journey, first to Istanbul and then east with the officer İsmail on Melih Pasha's orders, she is told by the chief physician Woodruff to go home, and Commander Halil Bey also objects. She stays regardless, in a region on the brink of war, torn between two loves. Michiel Huisman, Hera Hilmar, Josh Hartnett and Ben Kingsley star, with Haluk Bilginer also in the cast.

Against an estimated budget of about 40 million dollars, the film earned roughly 413,000 dollars. It was in the running for best original score at the 89th Academy Awards but did not pass the first round. Because it came out around the same time as The Promise, which deals with the Armenian genocide, some critics alleged it was made to deny that genocide, and it became a subject of controversy. Reviewers also found the script weak.

DirectorJoseph Ruben
The Ottoman Lieutenant The Ottoman Lieutenant

Reactions

You can pick up to 3 reactions.

Cast

Haluk Bilginer Haluk Bilginer Actor · 72 years old Michiel Huisman Hera Hilmar Josh Hartnett Ben Kingsley Affif Ben Badra

Through different eyes

History & Society Lens Asks about the period, the social background and what the work reflects.

Eastern Anatolia around 1915 is one of the heaviest and most historically contested settings of the First World War. A film set there will inevitably be judged by what it says, and does not say, about the great human tragedies of the period. Its release around the same time as The Promise, which deals with the Armenian genocide, led some critics to accuse it of serving genocide denial. Watching it without knowing about that dispute makes it hard to understand why the reaction was so harsh. For viewers curious about the era it is not an adequate source on its own; it needs to be weighed alongside other accounts of those years.

Cinephile Looks at script, editing and directing choices; keeps a distance from formula films.

The gulf between an estimated budget of about 40 million dollars and takings of roughly 413,000 is not a measure of quality in itself, but it sums up the gap between the epic scale the film aimed for and the response it found. Nor is it surprising that critics found the script weak: an idealistic woman torn between two loves on the edge of war is one of the most worn-out engines of the war romance. That engine hands characters a choice to make instead of building inner conflict, and confines the drama to the limits of a love triangle. Reaching the first round of Oscar consideration for original score suggests a certain level of craft, but in my view the weight of the cast cannot fill the hole the script leaves.

Action & Thriller Fan Puts pace, tension and set pieces first; little patience for slow drama.

If a title with a lieutenant in it and a story set in 1915 wartime has you expecting action, as it did me, be warned: this is essentially a love story. The war stays on the threshold, in the background; at the centre is a nurse wavering between two loves. The idea of a punishing sixty-day journey promises tension, but the film leans on its romance. Not the place to look if you want combat-driven pace.

These are not reader reviews: they are short editorial takes written from different viewer perspectives with AI assistance. Reader reviews are below.

Reviews (0)

Log in Log in to write a review.

Comments